Jennie's Custom Cakes

717-207-8860

  • Sign In

  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • My Account
  • Sign out

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • Get to Know Your Cake
  • New Menu
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • Reviews
    • Contact Us
    • FAQs
    • Get to Know Your Cake
    • New Menu

717-207-8860

Jennie's Custom Cakes

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Menu
  • Reviews
  • Contact Us
  • FAQs
  • Get to Know Your Cake
  • New Menu

Account


  • My Account
  • Sign out


  • Sign In
  • My Account

Welcome to the Menu Page

The items on the menu are not the only cakes that I make, but are representations of the style of cakes that I do and how much they have cost.  Your order cost may vary.


For a list of flavor options, please see "Build Your Own Cupcakes" at the bottom of the page. Please keep in mind that cupcake flavors are sold by the dozen. 1 flavor = 1 dozen

Find out more

Sculpted Custom Cakes

Sculpted cakes are so much fun to make and so challenging at the same time! The challenge is why most bakers won't do them. The majority of your cake will be actual cake, but certain parts may need to be made of rice crispy treats (which could be flavored), marzipan, or other product. These cakes take time to plan, so please contact me as far out as possible from your event as you can.

A sculpted cake of a roasted Thanksgiving turkey with stuffing and dressings.

Roasted Turkey

$215

Size: Turkey-sized

Cake: White

Filling: Raspberry

Icing: Raspberry Flavored Buttercream

Decor: Peanut butter rice crispy treat wings and legs with pretzel rod and marshmallow "bones", airbrushed color, black "pepper" sprinkles, twisted orange slices, raspberries, whipped cream and cake pieces "stuffing"


What looks like a full-sized, perfectly roasted and seasoned golden turkey is actually a CAKE! Everything is edible, even the leg bones!

Scuplted cake of a sitting unicorn with pink hooves, pink, purple, and blue hair, and golden horn.

Sitting Pretty Unicorn

$200

Size: 17" to the top of the horn

Cake: Chocolate

Filling: Raspberry

Icing: Raspberry Buttercream

Decor: Cake pop ears and horn, piped dots to give it that fuzzy look, colorful mane and tail


It's a cake so cute that you just wanna hug it!! Customize with your favorite colors for the mane and tail or the hooves or even the body! Adorable head tilt is included!

A sculpted cake of a Roblox character sitting on a cake carrier.

Cool_Wolf_22 (A Roblox Character)

$80

Size: too tall for my "average" cake carrier

Cake: Banana

Filling: Banana flavored buttercream

Icing: Banana flavored buttercream

Decor: Airbrushed


My nephew wanted his birthday cake to be his Roblox character that he designed.  He also wanted it to be banana flavored ...  


No problem!  I used a picture of a computer screen to create a sitting version of the little dude that could also fit in my "average" sized cake carrier for the trip to my sister's house.  He LOVED it!

Philadelphia Eagles Cake

$100

Size: 8" around the base, 6" around the top, about 8" tall

Cake: Coconut

Filling: Pineapple

Icing: Coconut Cream Cheese

Decor: Airbrushed feathers, gray chocolate coated rice crispie beak, marzipan eyes.


If the logo was a real bird, what would it look like?

Alien coming out of spaceship cake with working lights surrounded by cupcakes with baby alien decor.

Alien Spaceship with Lights & Cupcakes

$210

Size: 8" around the middle, about 9" tall

Cake: Banana

Filling: Cream cheese Icing

Icing: Cream cheese

Decor: Airbrushed, piping, working lights, and an alien saying Hi!


One of my favorites!  How many people have a cake that lights up!! 


For more pictures, see the gallery.  

Baby T-Rex Scultpd Cake with grass and sugar cookie number 3

Baby T-Rex

Size: two cake layers tall, about 18" nose to tail

Cake: 

Filling: 

Icing: 

Decor: Airbrushed, marzipan eyes and nails, piped grass field, sugar cookie and chocolate bone and 3


A dinosaur themed cake OR a cake that IS a dinosaur?


Specialty Cakes

These cakes have a special flare to them, but aren't carved into shapes like the sculpted cakes.

Red round cake with tiger stripes. Fondant bamboo, leaves, and flower decorations and a hand painted

Red Tiger Cake

$150

Size: 8"

Cake: Vanilla

Filling: Red Buttercream

Icing: Red Buttercream

Decor: A hand painted sugar cookie tiger, dried fondant tiger stripes, bamboo logs, leaves, and flowers, a fondant and royal icing handwritten message banner.


A wildly adorable tiger themed birthday suprise!

The top of a cake with piped buttercream dots in the shape of the FSU logo

Florida State University Cake

$140

Size: 8"

Cake: Loaded Carrot Cake

Filling: Cream Cheese Icing

Icing: Cream Cheese Flavored Buttercream

Decor: Piping dots to look like the Florida State University logo


When you need a cake for Dad and he's an FSU fan ...

Tennesse Titans logo shaped strawberry flavored cake

Tennesse Titans Cake

$140

Size: Half Sheet, Semi-Sculpted

Cake: Strawberry

Filling: Strawberry Buttercream

Icing: Buttercream

Decor: Piping dots to look like the Tennessee Titans logo


What better way is there to incorporate a favorite team into a birthday? 

A round cake with cresting airbrushed waves around the sides. Graham cracker "sand" surrounds the cake in the box.

Ocean Waves Cake

$73

Size: 8"

Cake: Chocolate

Filling: Vanilla Buttercream

Icing: Vanilla Buttercream

Decor: Airbrushed waves with white crests and graham cracker sand


Get creative!  Add your own baby shark cake pick, mermaid toy, palm tree, or message to top it off. 

A Patriotic American Flag Cake with lit candles. Each slice of this round cake looks like the American flag.

American Flag Cake

$105

Size: 8 "

Cake: Colored White Cake

Filling: Cream Cheese Icing

Icing: Buttercream

Decor: Buttercream Piping


A patriotic slice for everyone!  You could change the flavor of the cake and icing and even swap the filling for another white filling, like buttercream or whipped cream icing.

Dark blue piping and a centered rose lines the bottom of a yellow buttercream cake draped in pearls.

Beauty and the Beast Cake

$85

Size: 6"

Cake: Chocolate

Filling: "The Gray Stuff" (Oreo Cream Cheese Icing)

Icing: Buttercream

Decor: Hand placed pearl candies, gold edible glitter and a candy rose.


A "free-style within my budget" Beauty and the Beast cake.  Toys were provided by client.

Pink Ombre Hawaiian Drip Cake

Pink Hawaiian Ombre

$175

Cake: 

Filling: 

Icing: Strawberry Buttercream

Decor: Pink ombre, pink and green macarons, fondant flowers, pink and green sixlet "drip", and non-edible foliage




Flavor Themed Cakes

Are you a die-hard Reese's fan? Or Oreos? Or pistachio? Or black forest? You came to the right place!

Reese's Chocolate cake. Reese's pieces and Reese's peanut butter cups top a rich chocolate and peanut butter iced cake.

Reese's Cake

$95

An 8" round, rich, moist, triple chocolate cake is layered, filled and covered with creamy peanut butter buttercream, topped with ganache, Reese's cups and pieces.  The big suprise is inside.  It's stuffed with more Reese's pieces!

Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cake with Dipped Strawberries on top

Chocolate Covered Strawberry Cake

$

This is most intense strawberry flavor that you will ever find in a cake! Two layers of 8" round strawberry cake are stacked and filled with a chocolate buttercream. Then it's covered in an intense strawberry buttercream. The top is draped in chocolate ganache and decorated with dipped berries. 

Carrot cake with cream cheese icing, walnuts, dried cranberries, coconut & pineapple too.

Loaded Carrot Cake

$

This 8" carrot cake has optional add-ins! You can add walnuts, raisins, dry cranberries or other fruit, coconut, and pineapple. Want to add something else? Let me know! And, of course, it's layered and covered in cream cheese icing!

Strawberries and Cream Cake. Real strawberry cake, whipped cream filling, buttercream, & drizzle.

Strawberries and Cream Cake

$

Strawberries all day long! This is an 8" double layer real strawberry cake filled with a real strawberry infused whipped cream filling and coated in real strawberry buttercream and drizzle.  Sensing a theme?



A square naked Neopolitan cake topped with cream cheese icing, fresh cut and whole strawberries and chocolate shavings.

Neopolitan & Naked

$100

A LARGE (49 serving) flavor packed cake!


Chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry cakes sandwich one of the best tasting fillings - a pudding / whipped cream mix!  The edges are lined in a bold tasting cream cheese icing, which also adorns the top alongside fresh strawberries and shaved chocolate.

Strawberry cake and buttercream with lemon curd filling

Strawberry Lemonade Cake

$

Cake: Strawberry

Filling: Lemon Curd

Icing: Strawberry Buttercream

Decor: Candied Lemon Slices (not pictured)


Bursting with flavor! The strawberry cake and buttercream are made with a real strawberry reduction that pairs perfectly with a homemade lemon curd and candied .

Cupcakes

Just like with the flavor themed cakes, you can overload on your favorites with cupcakes!

Creme Brulee Cupcakes

Creme Brulee Cupcakes

$52 / dozen

Vanilla cupcakes are filled with vanilla pudding to start these off right! Homemade vanilla custard is coated in layers of sugar, each one caramelized into a warm bubbly crust.  Fresh whipped cream and seasonal berry or topping of your choice caps off each delicate little cake.

Chocolate cupcake with peanut butter buttercream, chopped Reese's and chocolate drizzle.

Reese's Cupcakes

$36 / dozen

A mini version of the Reese's Cake! A rich, moist, triple chocolate cake is filled with Reese's pieces and covered with creamy peanut butter buttercream, then topped with chopped Reese's cups and a chocolate drizzle.

Salted Caramel Cupcakes

$36 / dozen

Caramel flavored cake filled with a thick caramel sauce, caramel buttercream with a caramel drizzle on top then sprinkled with a course salt for a little fun.

"Mounds" of Coconut Cupcakes

$36 / dozen

Chocolate cupcakes are topped with coconut icing, rolled in finely shredded coconut and drizzled in more chocolate.

Red velvet cupcake with Jack Daniels cream cheese icing

Red Velvet JD

$42 / dozen

Nothing better than a red velvet cupcake with smooth Jack Daniel's cream cheese icing on top!  

Tropical Paradise Cupcakes

$42 / dozen

This soft coconut cake is filled with a pineapple reduction and topped with a coconut cream cheese icing.  


Build Your Own Cupcakes

YOU PICK! If you could choose any flavor cake, filling, icing and topping, ... what would YOU pick? Minimum order of 1 dozen per combination.

Chocolate cupcakes with no iicing

Cakes

Price varies

Chocolate

Vanilla

Strawberry

Lemon

Lemon Blueberry

Almond (white cake)

Orange

Coconut

Banana

Raspberry

Butter

Loaded Carrot 

Maple


Don't see your flavor? Ask!

Chocolate cupcakes filledwith white icing

Fillings

Price varies

Buttercreams and Cream Cheese icings - vanilla, almond, strawberry, orange, butter pecan, black walnut, banana, pineapple, coconut, lemon, mint, raspberry, chocolate, caramel, hazelnut, peanut butter, white chocolate, cinnamon vanilla

Curds - orange, pineapple, lemon

Pie filling - raspberry, cherry, strawberry, cinnamon apple

Puddings

Whipped Cream 

Whipped Topping

Candies - whole or chopped 

Chocolate Ganache


Don't see your flavor? Ask!

Pink swirl of icing

Icings

Price varies

Buttercreams and Cream Cheese icings - vanilla, almond, strawberry, orange, butter pecan, black walnut, banana, pineapple, coconut, lemon, mint, raspberry, chocolate, caramel, maple, hazelnut, peanut butter, white chocolate, cinnamon vanilla

Whipped Cream

Whipped Topping

Chocolate Ganache


Don't see your flavor? Ask!

Candies

Toppings

Price varies

Of course you can have multiple on yours!  If you want something that isn't listed, just ask.


Sprinkles - rainbow, nonpareils, colored, fall leaves, black cats, pumpkins, gingerbread men, flowers

Sugar crystals - choice of color

Candies - you name it, M&M's, chopped Reese's cups, Reese's pieces, rock candy

Cookie pieces - Oreo, chocolate chip, wafers

Drizzles (may get messy) - chocolate, strawberry, caramel

Other - course salt, Fruity Pebbles, nuts, fruits, bacon


Don't see your flavor? Ask!


Copyright © 2019 Jennie's Custom Cakes - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by GoDaddy

Closed until further notice!

My home bakery will be closed to new orders until, at least, Nov 2023! Please see the home page for recommendations on other great bakers in the area.

See Recommendations

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept